iKnife Collector

The online community of knife collectors

You know you see all the knife reviews on YouTube showing everything from a young kid holding a knife the whole time talking about it- all the way to a guy out hacking on trees.

I've got to ask- What makes for a good knife review? 

I'm talking about more than the cinematography here- I'm talking content- meat. What are the most important points for you for the review to be a good (almost professional level) review?

I'm assuming the same points apply to a written review as is important in a vid review too, so if there's a different to you there, what is it?

Thanks for your help? 

Tags: knife review

Views: 7

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

standardized testing
standardized results
Standardized units (in*lbs of force, Rockwell C scale for hardness, ...)
verifiable repeatable evidence

analyze what concrete information/data is desired .. then .. design test methodology to provide that data ..

Example: Test & evaluate the robustness of a locking system.

Desired data = the overturning moment (OTM) expressed in inch*pounds (in*lbs) required to compromise a locking system.

define a std test config such that test knives are supported in like fashion .. different blade lengths can be accomodated w/o compromising test integrity .. a static load (force in lbs) is applied to the open blade a given distance (dist in inches) from the pivot point .. force applied in the direction that most compromises the lock .. define sample pool size ..

I'm doin this off the cuff .. the test procedure would include test jigs, diagrams defining direction of forces, definition of test procedures, etc.

Test results provide a quantifiable verifiable repeatable concrete means of comparing locking system "X" and locking system "Y" .. the OTM at which a system fails ..

If sytem "A" fails @ 29 in*lbs .. system "B" fails @ 87 in*lbs .. system "C" fails @ 48 in*lbs ... locking system "B" is the most robust.

.. sure .. there are other considerations on a more personal "i like/dislike" level .. unless the results are close .. the > OTM : the more robust ..

I've found this more useful than .. it took joe's boy 6 hacks to get through this .. oh .. about 3" tree. Last time it took him less than 30 seconds to get through a similiar tree w/ that other knife ...

alright .. exaggerating to make a pt .. but .. you get the idea ..
Also .. analyze system failure .. can tell you ALOT !!!

catastrophic failure testing is FUN and extremely informative .. quite often .. identifies the next weakest component/design aspect !!!
"a good (almost professional level) review"

obtain the Request for Quote (RFQ) specs the military issued for knives like Gerber's assisted/auto issued to our troups .. farm out the testing to an independent lab .. test to the RFQ specs .. witnessing the test is part of the tuition .. I've never been denied pics for inclusion in a report ..
Scott

.. military RFQ specs have got to be out there for .. everything the military has used ..

.. straight knives .. tacticals .. autos .. machete's .. hatchets ..

.. an established criteria of acceptance has already been defined ..

reviews/tests relative to these specs could hold somewhat universal appeal .. military historian .. interest in tacticals .. survivalist .. straight knives .. specs for custom knives to exceed ..

standardized specs & tests that will be hard to argue with .. certainly .. not subjective !!
troops
Wow! Dale this is good detailed info. Thank you.

Question: Do you do reviews ever? Sounds like you need to. Might have a place for the reviews if you do :)
Scott,

The specs & performance criteria called out in MIL-K-818D are not severe. They were for a peace time utility knife.

But, what a great starting point. The performance criteria held important are identified. Measurement & qualification standards are defined. Individual tests are defined for each “important” performance criteria.

Not everything called out may be important or practical for the purposes of a review. Pick & choose within the limits of available resources and the needs for the review.

Now .. if a similar document for a tactical currently being issued to our troops could be located ….

Dale.
Good idea, Dale.

If anyone here has contacts with any tactical makers who sold to the US Gov for the wars, please help us out. I know the VP of Sales at KaBar.
Well first off, the best reviewer I have seen on youtube so far is Nutnfancy. Mostly before his reviews are consistent. He doesn't hold back when criticizing something either. Sometimes he does over criticize a little but most of the time he is very fair. Dale you should definitely do some reviews!
Thanks Jake .. I'm doin a little research in that direction .. we'll see what comes of it ..

Check out the Mil Spec for this military utility EDC .. attached pdf .. I was thinking of evaluating some current production EDC's to this std .. what do you think ??

What I'd really like is to obtain the RFQ specs that were issued for a current military tactical .. like the Gerber assisted/auto our troops are being issued .. then, evaluate current production tacticals to the same standards ..

Mil spec & defined test procedures were determined after exhaustive comprehensive analysis .. they've succesfully withstood the onslaught of many a hungry vendor .. AND .. they're objective & repeatable !!
Attachments:
Well Scott, Here's what I look for. When I run across a review, especially one about knives, I like to see all the specs on it. Then perhaps a no-nonsense performance test that the everyday user would face. I think an honest review would span a given length of time like say a month ? or so, of everyday usage. In a video, I like to see the "how it's made" kind of thing. I find those very interesting and after watching a few of those I get a good sense of the quality of the knife. A good site for this other than u-tube is World knives LTD. Check it out if you get a few minutes to spare.
Eliel
Check out my channel...http//:www.youtube.com/ftwcm

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Badge

Loading…

The online community of knife collectors

What is iKnife Collector?

iKnife Collector is a community of like mined friends who like to talk about knives.

Throw in the mix... groups for guns and dogs and it makes a perfect setting for discussion of all the things you like.

If you are joining Welcome! There is a lot to see and do.

If you are a returning member, we'd love to hear from you. Post pictures, and join in discussions. Enjoy the new chat and most of all have a great experience here on iKnife Collector!

Follow iKnifeCollector on Twitter

Follow iKnifeCollector on Twitter

Latest Activity

Sue OldsWidow left a comment for F.A.Phineas Spencer
37 minutes ago
biglmbass replied to Jan Carter's discussion Tell us about your newest in the group Great Eastern Cutlery
37 minutes ago
Sue OldsWidow left a comment for F.A.Phineas Spencer
39 minutes ago
Sue OldsWidow liked keesha kelly's photo
41 minutes ago
biglmbass liked Tom Peterson's photo
45 minutes ago
biglmbass liked Tom Peterson's photo
45 minutes ago
biglmbass liked Tom Peterson's photo
45 minutes ago
biglmbass liked Tom Peterson's photo
46 minutes ago
Pat ChoKo liked Smiling-Knife's discussion Military Knives
46 minutes ago
Pat ChoKo liked Jeremi Lett's photo
47 minutes ago
Pat ChoKo liked Lee Saunders's blog post My Barlows All Pretty In a Box
47 minutes ago
Pat ChoKo commented on Pat ChoKo's group Condor Tool & Knife
51 minutes ago
Pat ChoKo replied to Pat ChoKo's discussion Your Next Condor in the group Condor Tool & Knife
52 minutes ago
Smiling-Knife replied to Smiling-Knife's discussion Military Knives in the group BOX FULL OF KNIVES
1 hour ago
Steve"Hog"Hanner commented on keesha kelly's photo
1 hour ago
Gerald Hines left a comment for F.A.Phineas Spencer
1 hour ago
Cesar Salazar left a comment for F.A.Phineas Spencer
1 hour ago
Profile IconF.A.Phineas Spencer and john hosey joined iKnife Collector
1 hour ago
Herb Hoover replied to Jan Carter's discussion Tell us about your newest in the group Great Eastern Cutlery
2 hours ago
Clint Thompson replied to Jan Carter's discussion Tell us about your newest in the group Great Eastern Cutlery
2 hours ago

© 2012   Created by Scott King.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service