Welcome Home....******......This week Wed night Chat is PUMA Knives join us at 9PM EDT
Join/Renew NKCA....19.95 Membership pricing during the membership drive

The online community of knife collectors

My Barlows All Pretty In a Box

I finally put my Barlows in a Box. I don't really like the box for these knives, I think I will swap out those smaller Coca-Cola knives and find something else for the Barlows, but it's better than throwing them in a cardboard box.

On the left side are various makers including Case, Boker, Maherr & Grosh and others.

On the right are my antique Russells. All are 1800s. I have a few more that I need to dig up that are 1920-30 Russells.

I also have a few Daddy/Grand-Daddy Barlows.

Contest:

I haven't had one of these for months and the first one was a lot of fun.

Therre are two here that I don't think are actually Barlows although that is what they were sold as.

Can you spot them? Remember...I'm talking about what my sick brain says are not Barlows. I admit that I could be wrong.

First person to pick both with no wrong answers will get 2 Barlows not shown here (both are Prov. Cut. Co., nothing to write home about).

First person to get one right will get one of those Prov. Cut. Co's.

If someone gets one right & then someone gets the 2nd right you split the Prov. Cut. Co's.

Fair? Understandable rules??

Deadline: 5 pm Pacific Time on Wednesday, June 6th...yes 2012!!

Good luck!

Below is the box. On the left are the various makers. On the right are the Russells.

Below are the various makers (ignore the few on the right)

Below are the Russells (ignore those on the left).

3 members like this

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of iKnife Collector to add comments!

Join iKnife Collector

manager Comment by Steve Hanner on June 1, 2012 at 17:14: By the way Lee JJ on a short trip due back Sunday so we''l have to notify him via email...boy will he be surprised!

Comment by Robert Burris on June 1, 2012 at 16:48: I gotta give em a chance.lol

Comment by Lee Saunders on June 1, 2012 at 16:32: I've been waiting for you to jump in and win Robert! hahah

Comment by Robert Burris on June 1, 2012 at 15:30: Lee, I know the answer but I want to give everyone a chance. I don't want to win every time.lol

Comment by Lee Saunders on June 1, 2012 at 12:27: So here is my take so far:

JJ nailed one of them! The second from the bottom was sold to me as a Barlow but I just can't call it that. The bolster is too short even though the shape of the knife is right.

Plus the blade...I will post pics. The seller said the knife has a "match-srike" blade, but to me the area he is talking about is more like a bloodletting area maybe for hunting or fishing, so when you stick the blade in the blood has a channel to flow out. I could be wrong. The knife is a Friedman & Lauterjung Celebrated Cutlery (1864-1909) blade.

The candystripe is a Case Tested XX and although the handles are quirky for a Barlow I think that's what it is. The shape is exact to a regular Barlow.

Same with the top knife. Exact shape plus the handles are flat like the old saw-cut handles. That knife is a Maher and Grosh (1875 to present). Different, with the jigged iron handles, but I think it is a Barlow.

So JJ has one of em, but there is still one guess to go and one knife to win.

Comment by stephen tungate on June 1, 2012 at 11:33: i also have to agree with jj the1rst one on left all metal and the 2nd one from the bottom on left with short bolster.i have never seen barlows that look like them two. lee......

Comment by D ale on May 31, 2012 at 22:28: Actually .. I think JJ nailed it.

Comment by D ale on May 31, 2012 at 22:24: The Candy stripe scaled unit (3rd from top left) & the short bolster ??electricians knife?? (2cnd up from the btm left).

Moderator Comment by J.J. Smith III on May 31, 2012 at 21:55: I'm saying the top one, that looks like it has metal handled and the second from the bottom with the short bolster.

That's what MY sick brain says.

manager Comment by Steve Hanner on May 31, 2012 at 21:44: You are just so organized Lee! You have given me some inspiration, maybe I can get there someday!